Community energy · 05

Network tariffs by electrical proximity: why a kWh from the next-door substation should not cost the same as one from across the country

Today a community member would pay distribution charges on a shared kilowatt-hour exactly as on energy that crossed the whole power system. We propose that NEURC develop a methodology under which the charge depends on which parts of the network the energy actually used. For volumes within one transformer substation a zero variable component may prove justified, but only after a cost review.

Proposal sent to the regulator
Checked against sources
21 Nov 2026
Reading time
7 min

Status of this page

  • In force

    Law in force

    Art. 58-2(4) of Law 2019-VIII requires non-discriminatory procedures and economically justified tariffs for communities. Art. 58-1(7): no distribution or transmission charge is paid on energy from third-party installations connected to the active consumer’s own networks – already an equivalent of tier L0 in force. The law sets no reduction for sharing over the DSO network.

  • Draft, not adopted

    NEURC draft of 4 Nov 2026

    Draft p. 10.3.16: members pay distribution and transmission “at tariffs set by the Regulator”. The draft has no separate tariff for local sharing.

  • Proposal sent to the regulator

    Wesfin Flex proposals

    GEO-TAR-01 (No. 66): do not block a future differentiated tariff in the retail rules. GEO-SUP-08: proximity confirmed by the operator. GEO-TAR-02: direction for a separate tariff methodology.

  • Illustration, not a tariff

    Tiers L0–L4 and percentages

    A Wesfin analytical hypothesis for discussion. Not set by NEURC and not a tariff in force.

The problem

Distribution tariffs in Ukraine are set for each distribution system operator (DSO), mostly as a charge per kilowatt-hour, separately for two voltage classes. A household on 0.4 kV pays the second-class rate, which recovers the cost of every network level “above” it: 10/0.4 kV transformers, 10 kV lines, 35–110 kV substations. Suppliers separately pay a transmission tariff to the transmission system operator.

When a school takes energy from a rooftop plant on a neighbouring building fed by the same substation, that energy never rises to 10 kV, let alone 110 kV. Yet under current logic it is charged as if it had travelled the whole way. For households this nearly wipes out the point of a community: in the apartment-building scenario, with full network charges a shared kilowatt-hour is “worth” less than selling the surplus.

Tiers of electrical proximity

Tiers L0–L4: which parts of the network shared energy uses
  1. L0
    Behind one connectionRooftop PV and the flats of one building: no public network between them
  2. L1
    One 10/0.4 kV substationneighbouring buildings, a school and a workshop on the 0.4 kV lines of one transformer
  3. L2
    One 10 kV feederseveral transformers on one medium-voltage line; energy is transformed twice
  4. L3
    One 35–110 kV substationdifferent feeders sharing one DSO supply substation in the district
  5. L4
    Beyond: region, national gridpoints connected only via the transmission grid; no local benefit

Wesfin concept. Voltage classes simplified.

What the energy uses at each tier and what must be proven
TierWhere generation and consumption areNetwork elements usedWhat the DSO confirms
L0Behind one connection pointNo public DSO network. Already in force for an active consumer: Art. 58-1(7)Internal network layout and owner; right to operate it
L10.4 kV lines of one 10(6)/0.4 kV substationLow-voltage lines and possibly substation busbars; no step-upMetering points belong to one substation; no reverse flow through the transformer in those intervals
L2Different substations on one 10 kV feeder0.4 kV lines, two 10/0.4 kV transformers, part of a 10 kV lineMetering points on one feeder in the normal configuration
L3Different feeders of one 35–110 kV substationThe district medium-voltage networkOne supply substation
L4AnywhereThe whole grid, including transmissionNothing: ordinary rules

The scale follows the direction Wesfin Flex proposed for a separate tariff proceeding in the GEO-TAR-02 justification: class A – an internal network behind one point of connection; B – one feeder or substation; C – a localised regional area.

What share of the variable component to pay

Illustrative share of the variable network component by tier
L1One 0.4 kV substation0 %
L2One 10 kV feeder25 %
L3One DSO substation50 %
L4No verified proximity100 %

Share of the variable distribution-tariff component that would apply to a verified local volume. An illustration of the Wesfin concept, not a tariff in force and not a NEURC calculation.

Example: a municipality with 150 kW PV, 132,000 kWh of shared energy a year
TierShare of variable componentRate, UAH/kWhNetwork charge per year, UAH
L10 %0.000
L225 %0.5066,000
L350 %1.00132,000
L4100 %2.00264,000
Illustrative variable network component UAH 2.00/kWh. Charges on the residual energy members still take from their supplier are unchanged. An illustration, not a tariff.

These percentages are not the result of a calculation but a starting point for discussion. Real coefficients must come from a cost analysis of a specific DSO: what part of its allowed revenue relates to higher network levels, how losses change with local consumption, and what reserve capacity for community members costs when the sun is not shining.

Is zero possible?

Yes, but only for the variable component and only for verified volumes at tier L1 or L0. The argument: a per-kWh charge should reflect the costs that kilowatt-hour causes. Energy consumed in the same 15-minute interval behind the same substation does not load 10 kV lines, higher-level transformers or the transmission system, and losses on a short 0.4 kV section are often lower than for delivery from distant generation.

Zero does not mean “the network is free”. The substation, 0.4 kV cables, maintenance, metering and reserve capacity are still needed by members, who draw from the grid in the evening and in winter. These costs must be recovered in another way: through charges on residual consumption, a fixed or capacity component, or another part of the tariff. Where no such component exists, zero on shared energy shifts costs onto other consumers, which is cross-subsidy.

  • What must be proven for zero: the volume is measured by certified interval data; the DSO confirmed the metering points sit behind one substation; shared energy does not exceed the member’s actual consumption in the interval; in that interval there was no flow through the transformer in the other direction beyond local consumption.
  • What the methodology must include: 0.4 kV losses; the cost of reserve; how the DSO’s fixed costs are recovered; the effect on other consumers’ tariffs; a volume cap based on substation capacity.
  • How to test it: a pilot on several substations with a public report and annual review of coefficients, as in Austria, where the regulator sets the reduction every year.

Why this benefits more than community members

  • Less load on higher network levels in sunny hours, when distribution networks are already often strained by reverse flows from private solar.
  • An incentive to build generation where demand is, not where land is cheaper, reducing the need for network reinforcement.
  • A signal for storage and flexible demand: charging a battery or a water heater from a neighbour’s solar becomes better than exporting the surplus.
  • Resilience: communities organised around one substation are natural candidates for island operation during outages, which Wesfin Flex addressed in submission No. 37 on local network resilience zones.

What already works in the EU

How EU countries link network charges to proximity
CountryProximity criterionWhat the community gets
AustriaLocal zone (one substation, low voltage) and regional zone (one substation, medium voltage)A reduced variable network rate, set yearly by E-Control
ItalyOne primary substation (cabina primaria)A premium per shared MWh and a partial refund of network costs
SpainOne substation, 500 m or one cadastral parcelA simplified collective self-consumption scheme
PortugalShared energy through the public gridSpecific access tariffs, no losses charged
Details and sources in How Europe does it.

EU law requires network charges for communities to be cost-reflective, and communities to contribute fairly to overall system costs (Directive 2019/944, Art. 16; Directive 2018/2001, Art. 22). In the EU a reduction is justified by lower costs, not by a social goal.

What the regulator should do

  1. Keep the option open in the retail rules

    Adopt the clarification of p. 10.3.2 as worded in GEO-TAR-01: payment at the Regulator’s tariffs and methodologies, including differentiated ones once introduced.

    Now, in the community resolution

  2. A procedure to confirm proximity

    Distribution Code: DSO response time, an exhaustive list of grounds for refusal, protection of network information (GEO-SUP-08).

    Distribution Code

  3. Tariff proceeding

    Cost analysis by voltage level for several DSOs, public consultation on coefficients, impact assessment for other consumers.

    Separate NEURC methodology

  4. Pilot and monitoring

    Several substations with different profiles, a public report, annual review.

    1–2 years

Sources

  1. Law No. 2019-VIII on the Electricity Market, Art. 58-2 (in Ukrainian) (opens in a new tab) · Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine

    In force: non-discriminatory procedures, economically justified tariffs, DSO cooperation.

  2. NEURC draft resolution of 4 Nov 2026 (in Ukrainian) (opens in a new tab) · NEURC

    A draft, not adopted. Points 10.3.2 and 10.3.16 as quoted in submissions Nos. 59 and 66.

  3. Wesfin Flex submission No. 66 of 17 Nov 2026 (GEO-TAR-01, GEO-SUP-08, GEO-TAR-02; PDF, Ukrainian) · Wesfin Flex LLC

    Proposals sent to the regulator. Not adopted.

  4. Register of Wesfin Flex submission No. 37 of 8 Oct 2026 (Ukrainian) · Wesfin Flex LLC
  5. Distribution System Code (NEURC resolution No. 310, in Ukrainian) (opens in a new tab) · NEURC
  6. Directive (EU) 2019/944, Art. 16 (opens in a new tab) · EUR-Lex
  7. Directive (EU) 2018/2001, Art. 22 (opens in a new tab) · EUR-Lex
  8. Detailwissen: Nahebereich und Netzentgelte (opens in a new tab) · Austrian Coordination Office for Energy Communities

This is an explanatory text by Wesfin, not legal advice. Legal acts are quoted from official texts as of the check date; verify the current version before acting.

Read next