Learn · 03
Community economics: scenarios for apartment blocks, municipalities, households and small business
Whether a community pays off depends on three numbers: what share of generation members use in the same interval, what the energy it replaces costs, and what part of the network tariff is still paid on a shared kilowatt-hour. We modelled four typical scenarios with open assumptions.
How to read these numbers
We calculate the total benefit to the community – members and the organisation together. The internal price members pay the community for their share only splits that benefit: the lower the price, the more members save and the less the community earns for maintenance and investment recovery. That is why the tables have no internal price.
The value of one shared kilowatt-hour is the price a member would otherwise pay the supplier, minus the part of the network tariff still payable on shared energy. We show three cases: the full variable component (as for ordinary energy), half, and zero. These are tiers L4, L3 and L1 of the proximity tariff concept.
| Parameter | Value | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Annual PV yield | 1,100 kWh per kW | Average estimate for central Ukraine; check PVGIS for a specific site |
| PV turnkey cost | UAH 25,000 per kW | Assumed, including installation and connection |
| Storage cost | UAH 12,000 per kWh of capacity | Assumed |
| Household price | UAH 4.32/kWh | The fixed household price level set from 1 Jun 2024; check the current price |
| Public-sector price | UAH 9/kWh incl. VAT | Assumed, including network tariffs |
| Small-business price | UAH 7.5/kWh excl. VAT | Assumed, for a VAT payer |
| Variable network component in the price | UAH 2/kWh | Assumed: transmission + distribution |
| Surplus sale price | UAH 2.5/kWh | Assumed market price in sunny hours |
The key number: the share used at the same time
The sun shines during the day, while households consume most in the morning and evening. A school, a water utility or a workshop works in the daytime. So the mix of members matters more than the size of the plant: a municipality with a school and a pumping station uses a far larger share of generation than a few residential buildings.
Per day: generation ≈ 197 kWh, used in the same interval ≈ 175 kWh (89% of generation), the rest is surplus to the grid. Demand ≈ 363 kWh, of which 48% is covered by the PV.
An assumed clear-day profile, not measured data.
In the example, the mixed community uses most of the generation in the same interval. Everything that does not coincide becomes surplus and is sold for less. Storage raises the shared portion but costs money itself – as the village scenario shows.
Scenario 1. Apartment block: 60 flats and 40 kW on the roof
The owners’ association installs 40 kW on the roof and shares the energy between flats and common needs (lifts, pumps, lighting). Some residents are at home during the day, so about 70 % of generation is used at the same time.
| Item | Network: 100% of variable component (L4) | 50% (L3) | 0% (L1) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual generation | 44,000 kWh | ||
| Used by members in the same interval | 30,800 kWh (70 %) | ||
| Surplus exported | 13,200 kWh | ||
| Value of 1 shared kWh, UAH | 2.32 | 3.32 | 4.32 |
| Annual community benefit, UAH | 64,456 | 95,256 | 126,056 |
| Simple payback, years | 15.5 | 10.5 | 7.9 |
Conclusion: with the full network charge, a shared kilowatt-hour is “worth” only UAH 2.32 to a household – less than the surplus sale price. Then a community makes no economic sense: selling all energy is simpler. If the plant and the flats sit behind one connection or on one substation and the tariff reflects that, payback almost halves.
Scenario 2. Municipality: school, water utility and town hall
A village or town council builds 150 kW on a school roof. Members are the school, the water utility’s pumping station and the town hall, all daytime loads, so about 80 % of generation is used at the same time.
| Item | Network: 100% of variable component (L4) | 50% (L3) | 0% (L1) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual generation | 165,000 kWh | ||
| Used by members in the same interval | 132,000 kWh (80 %) | ||
| Surplus exported | 33,000 kWh | ||
| Value of 1 shared kWh, UAH | 7 | 8 | 9 |
| Annual community benefit, UAH | 891,500 | 1,023,500 | 1,155,500 |
| Simple payback, years | 4.2 | 3.7 | 3.2 |
Conclusion: for daytime loads paying a high energy price, a community pays back quickly even with the full network charge. The tariff matters less for payback, but hundreds of thousands of hryvnias of extra annual benefit are real money for a municipality.
Scenario 3. Village: 20 households and 50 kW
Villagers join to build 50 kW on a farmer’s barn on the same substation as their houses. Most people are at work during the day, so without storage only 45 % of generation is used at the same time. We modelled two variants: without storage and with a 100 kWh battery.
| Item | Network: 100% of variable component (L4) | 50% (L3) | 0% (L1) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual generation | 55,000 kWh | ||
| Used by members in the same interval | 24,750 kWh (45 %) | ||
| Surplus exported | 30,250 kWh | ||
| Value of 1 shared kWh, UAH | 2.32 | 3.32 | 4.32 |
| Annual community benefit, UAH | 88,045 | 112,795 | 137,545 |
| Simple payback, years | 14.2 | 11.1 | 9.1 |
| Item | Network: 100% of variable component (L4) | 50% (L3) | 0% (L1) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual generation | 55,000 kWh | ||
| Used by members in the same interval | 37,000 kWh (70 %, minus storage losses) | ||
| Surplus exported | 16,500 kWh | ||
| Value of 1 shared kWh, UAH | 2.32 | 3.32 | 4.32 |
| Annual community benefit, UAH | 58,090 | 95,090 | 132,090 |
| Simple payback, years | 42.2 | 25.8 | 18.5 |
Conclusion: for residential members, storage raises the shared portion from 45 % to 70 % but, at the assumed prices, does not pay for itself. Other sources of value make it worthwhile: backup during outages, flexibility services to the DSO through an aggregator, grants. Without them households should start with PV alone.
Scenario 4. Small business: a market or business park
Six small businesses (shops, a workshop, a cold store) put 100 kW on a warehouse roof. Their daytime demand is high and steady, so about 85 % of generation is used at the same time.
| Item | Network: 100% of variable component (L4) | 50% (L3) | 0% (L1) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual generation | 110,000 kWh | ||
| Used by members in the same interval | 93,500 kWh (85 %) | ||
| Surplus exported | 16,500 kWh | ||
| Value of 1 shared kWh, UAH | 5.5 | 6.5 | 7.5 |
| Annual community benefit, UAH | 475,500 | 569,000 | 662,500 |
| Simple payback, years | 5.3 | 4.4 | 3.8 |
Conclusion: the business case is the most robust. But the law limits members to micro and small enterprises; medium-sized businesses are not in the definition. Tax questions also need answers: VAT on the internal price and accounting for the community’s income.
What the scenarios show
| Scenario | No community (sell only) | L4: full network | L3: 50% | L1: 0% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apartment block, 40 kW | 14.3 | 15.5 | 10.5 | 7.9 |
| Municipality, 150 kW | 12.6 | 4.2 | 3.7 | 3.2 |
| Village, 50 kW | 13.5 | 14.2 | 11.1 | 9.1 |
| Village, 50 kW + storage | – | 42.2 | 25.8 | 18.5 |
| Small business, 100 kW | 12.8 | 5.3 | 4.4 | 3.8 |
- The member mix decides. Daytime consumers (schools, water utilities, businesses) make a community worthwhile under any tariff.
- For households the network tariff decides. Without recognising locality, a residential community under our assumptions is no better than simply selling the energy. This is why a differentiated network tariff is a precondition for residential communities at scale.
- Storage is an investment in resilience, not in savings, until flexibility is paid for.
- Small administrative costs matter. For an apartment block, UAH 20,000 a year for metering and reporting is a visible share of the benefit. Standard procedures and automated administration directly affect payback.
Sources
- PVGIS – Photovoltaic Geographical Information System (opens in a new tab) · European Commission Joint Research Centre
Tool for estimating PV output at a specific location.
- Law No. 2019-VIII, Arts. 1, 58-2 (in Ukrainian) (opens in a new tab) · Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine
Membership; communities in the form of owners’ associations.
- NEURC draft resolution of 4 Nov 2026 (in Ukrainian) (opens in a new tab) · NEURC
Network charges for members (draft pp. 10.3.2, 10.3.16).
This is an explanatory text by Wesfin, not legal advice. Legal acts are quoted from official texts as of the check date; verify the current version before acting.
Read next
- Learn
Network tariffs by electrical proximity: why a kWh from the next-door substation should not cost the same as one from across the country
The Wesfin concept: differentiated network charges for communities depending on whether energy stays within one 0.4 kV substation, one 10 kV feeder or the regional grid. Rationale, safeguards and EU examples.
- Learn
How energy sharing works in a community: metering, algorithms, roles
Physical flows versus accounting allocation, static and dynamic algorithms on 15-minute data, surplus, storage, a member’s bill and the roles of market parties.
- Learn
Commercial launch of a community: seven conditions before sharing becomes billing
What a community needs to move from a model to real settlement: a legal entity, contracts, verified metering points and EICs, official metering, an algorithm, financial settlement and work with suppliers and BRPs.